Comparison of physiopathology stage training program by course method and national medical program, Case Study (Mashhad University of Medical Sciences)

Gerivani, Atena; Behjati, Neda; Montazer Ataei, Mahbobeh; Karimi Monaghi, Hossein

doi:10.22038/hmed.2022.60017.1173

Comparison of physiopathology stage training program by course method and national medical program, Case Study (Mashhad University of Medical Sciences)

https://doi.org/10.22038/hmed.2022.60017.1173

Volume 13, Issue 4
Autumn 2022

Pages 39-29

Horizon of Medical Education Development

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Atena Gerivani ¹

Neda Behjati ¹

Mahbobeh Montazer Ataei ²

Hossein Karimi Monaghi ³

¹ School of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran

² Department of Educational Sciences, Mashhad Branch, Islamic Azad University, Mashhad, Iran.

³ Medical Surgical Nursing, School of Nursing and Midwifery, & Department of Medical Education, School of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran

Abstract

Introduction: This study aimed to compare the course curriculum of physiopathology and the national medical program at Mashhad University of Medical Sciences.
Materials & Methods: This descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted on 275 incoming students in 2017, of whom 135 were in the course method, and 140 were in the national medical program. The sampling method was the census, and an independent t-test was used to analyze the data. Research data were analyzed using SPSS software.
Results: The mean of the answers showed that the grade point average of physiopathology in the program was 15.99±2.36 with the course method, and the grade point average with the national medical program method was 16.70±1.14, which indicated that the average grade point average of the national medical program is higher than the course program.
Conclusion: Based on the results, changing the curriculum of the physiopathology degree from a course program to a national medical program can be considered as a suitable approach to improve the medical education process and academic performance of students whose GPA is higher compared to the course program.

Keywords

medical education

national curriculum

physiopathology

reform

1. Blake JE. The Consequential Effects of
High-Stakes Testing on Teacher Pedagogy.
Practice and Identity: Teacher Voices Disrupt the A
Priori [dissertation]. Knoxville, Tennessee:
University of Tennessee; 2008.
2. Loukzadeh Z. Mazloomy SS. Mirzaei M.
Strategies to improve the quality of medical
education. Journal of Medical Education and
Development. 2012;7(1): 71-74.
3. Zahedi M. Amir Maleki Tabrizi H. The
effectiveness of medical education from the
perspective of general medicine doctoral students
of Tehran University of Medical Sciences. Iranian
Journal of Medical Education. 2008; 7 (2): 289-98.
4. Yazdani S. Hatami S. General practitioner
in Iran. Tehran, Iran: Golbahar; 2004.
5. Heidari AA. Ghazi Moghaddam M.
Ebrahimi Garoui H. Challenges of general
medicine education in medical school of Mashhad
University of Medical Sciences. Qualitative Study.
Horizon of medical education development.
2021;12(3):35-49 .
6. Harelkin Bishop M. Soul-to-soul:
deconstructing defiict thinking in the classroom:
University of Saskatchewan. Saskatoon; 2013.
7. Alshynbayeva Z. Sarbassova K. Galiyeva
T. Kaltayeva G. Bekmagambetov A. On
Anticipatory Development of Dual Education
Based on the Systemic Approach. International
Journal of Environmental and Science Education.
2016;11(18):12540-50.
8. Zamani Z. Asadi I. Ameri Z. The need to
modify the educational curriculum of medical
sciences according to the coronavirus (COVID-19).
Horizon of medical education development.
Mashhad; 2021;13(3)95-85.
9. Saburi S. Etemad Ahri A. Maki Al-Agha
Badi A. Emadzadeh A. Curriculum model design
with a hidden and neglected curriculum approach
with regard to health system transformation and
innovation plan packages. Horizon of Development
of Medical Education. 2020;11(3):84-59.
10. Sum S. Alinegad S. Rastgar Z. Tashakkori
F. Khani A. Pourghasem M. Basic Science
Lecturer’s Perspectives on Integration in Babol
University of Medical Sciences. Iranian Journal of
Medical Education. 2013;12(11):807-16.
11. Dadvar L. Dadgari A. Mirzaei M. Rezaei
M. Assessing the achievement of the goals of
teaching basic clinical nursing skills by ASKI
method to final year nursing students in the ICU.
Journal of Knowledge and Health. 2014;9(4):31-24.
12. Dick MLB. King DB. Mitchell GK. Kelly
GD. Buckley JF. Garside SJ. Vertical Integration in
Teaching And Learning (VITAL): an approach to
medical education in general practice. Medical
journal of Australia. 2007;187(2):133-5.
13. Jones R. Higgs R. De Angelis C. Prideaux
D. Changing face of medical curricula. The Lancet.
2001;357(9257):699-703.
14. Valizadeh M. Mousavi Nasab N. Ahmadi
A. Rostami A. Comparison of course program with
semester of offering physiopathology courses in
Zanjan University of Medical Sciences. Iranian
Journal of Medical Education. 2013;13(3):201-11.
15. Yamani N. Shaterjalali M. Curriculum
integration with emphasis on integration into
medical education. Iranian Journal of Medical
Education. 2012;11(9):1202-13.
16. Haqqani F. Alavi M. Introducing some
new approaches in the field of clinical education.
Iranian Journal of Education in Medical Sciences
(Special Issue on Education Development).
2010;10(5):801-806.
17. Bahramian F. Bahmani Aghababaei A.
Evaluation of the results of changing the
arrangement of anatomy and embryology courses
on the scores of medical students of Isfahan
University of Medical Sciences. 2010;8(30):83-77.
18. Gerivani A. Sadeghi T. Karimi Moonaghi
H. Zendedel A. Integrating of Anatomy and
Physiology courses in basic medical sciences (case
study in Mashhad Faculty of Medicine). Future of
Medical Education Journal. 2020;10(4):46-50.
19. Seif A. Educational measurement,
measurement and evaluation. Tehran: Doran
Publications; 2021.
20. Sarabadani J. Karimi H. Farahmandi N.
Shokri M. Salehi A. Explain practical strategies to
improve the level of professionalism of dental
students of Mashhad University of Medical
Sciences. Horizon of Development of Medical
Education. Mashhad; 2022;13(3)75-62.
21. Regulations for the general medical
doctorate course, approved by the sixty-seventh
session of the High Council for Medical Sciences
Planning. Ministry of Health, Treatment and
Medical Education. Tehran; 2017.
22. Yazdani S. Hatami S. General practitioner
in Iran. Tehran: Golbahar; 2004.
23. Bahari A. Puramin, Spiritual, Woody.
Integration of general medicine physiopathology
curriculum in Mashhad University of Medical
Sciences. Horizon of medical education
development. 2016;7(2):29-32.
24. Valizadeh M. Mousavi Nasab SN.
Ahmadi A. Rostami A. Comparison of course
program with semester of offering physiopathology
courses in Zanjan University of Medical Sciences.
Iranian Journal of Medical Education. 2013;13(3):
201-11.
25. Valizadeh M. Mousavinasab SN.
Nahavandi F. Outcomes of Horizontal Integration
Program in Externship Phase of Medical Students.
Journal of Medical Education Development.
2011;3(5):56-62

XML

PDF 1.32 M