Authors
1
1. Medical Science Education Research Center, Medical Education Study and Development Center, Dental Science Research Center, Guilan University of Medical Sciences, Rasht, Iran
2
School of Dentistry, Guilan University of Medical Sciences, Rasht, Iran. Iran.
3
Department of Biostatistics, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Guilan University of Medical Sciences, Rasht, Iran.
4
Department of Nursing, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Guilan University of Medical Sciences, Rasht, Iran.
,
Document Type : Original Article
Abstract
Introduction: The phenomenon of teaching and its effective components from the past to this day has been one of the main concerns of theorists of education. This study has been done with the aim of evaluation of effective teaching characteristics based on postgraduate dental students' viewpoints all over the IRAN in 2020.
Materials & Methods: This Analytic Descriptive study was performed on 191 residents studying in dental schools in the country's medical science universities. The tool for collecting information was a web-based questionnaire including 33 items about research knowledge, teaching method, the ability to communicating with the residents and personal characteristics. inferential statistics (Wilcoxon one-sample, Mann-Whitney test, Kruskal Wallis test and Spearman correlation coefficient) were used in statistical analysis.
Results: The mean age of the participants was 29.42 ± 2.79 years and (58.6%) were females. The most important characteristic of the teacher in the opinion of residents in the field of research knowledge was to control the subject of teaching with (73.3%), in the field of teaching methods, teaching the contents clear (44%), in the field of ability of communication with the residents, close and friendly relationship with the residents (38.2%). and in the field of personal characteristics were criticism (47.1%) and respectful tone (45%). The highest averages were related to the individual characteristics 3.85±0.65 and the lowest averages were related to the teaching methods 3.81±0.71.The domains of professional characteristics and teaching methods in single assistants were significantly higher than home residents (p = 0.045 and p = 0.038, respectively).
Conclusion: The most important feature of effective teaching was having mastery of the subject of teaching and awareness of it and transparent and clear transmission of content. Also the personal characteristics of the professors, such as being critical and respectful tone are effective in the teaching characteristics of the professors.
1. Saif A.A. Modern educational
Psychology. Psychology of learning and
Instruction (6th edition), Tehran: Doran;
2010.
2. Labrague LJ. McEnroe-Petitte DM.
D'Souza MS. Hammad KS. Hayudini
JNA. Nursing faculty teaching
characteristics as perceived by nursing
students: an integrative review.
Scandinavian journal of caring sciences.
2020;34(1):23-33.
3. Sattary S. Assessment of effective
teaching, components based on the
student's viewpoints. Research in
Curriculum Planning. 2013;10(39):134-46.
4. MirarabRozi R. HajiTabartemeh M. Jafari
F. Comparison of the effective teaching
components of faculty members and
invited professors from the perspective of
the students. Scientific Journal
Management System 2018;6(3):206-17.
5. Akbari M. Moeintaghavi A. Ghanbari H.
Bagheri M. Atoofi A. A Comparison of
the Students’ and Teachers’ Viewpoints
about the Characteristics of a Good
Teacher in Dentistry. Journal of Mashhad
Dental School 2014;38(4):281-90.
6. Asadi M. Gholami K. Bolandhemtan K.
The University of Kurdistan's faculty and
students view on basic elements of
effective teaching. Faculty of Education
and Psychology. 2015;11(1):1-27.
7. Tofoghiyan T. Monadi H. Nasrollahi S.
Rakhshani MH. Prioritization of the
Effective Teaching Parameters;
Comparing the Viewpoints of Students
and Teachers of Sabzevar University of
Medical Sciences. Bimonthly Educational
Strategies in Medical Sciences.
2015;8(1):1-6.
8. Pourjavid S. Alibeygi A. Teaching
Effectiveness of Faculties: The Case of
Campus of Agriculture and Natural
Resources, Razi University. Higher
Education Letter. 2013;5(20):61-80.
9. Talebzade Shoshtari L. Khamesan A.
Pourshafei H. Attributions of Successful
Professors in Effective Teaching based on
Grounded Theory Method. Quarterly
Journal of New Thoughts on Education.
2017;13(3):211-28.
10. Eslamian H. Ealamian Z. karami M. Study
the Relationship of Applying the Criteria
for Effective Teaching by Faculty with
Students Morale Bitch. Research in
Curriculum Planning. 2018;15(56):132-47.
11. Rahbar S. Rahbar A. Mohebi S.
Gharlipour Z. Ghorbani E. Nikseresht S. et
al. Designing and Validating of the
Questionnaire of Factors Affecting
Teacher - Student Relationship from the
Point of View of Students of Qom
University of Medical Sciences. Qom
University of Medical Sciences Journal.
2020;13(12):75-86.
12. Seyyedmajidi M. Seyyedmajidi A.
Habibzadehbijani F. Khodadadi E.
Motalebnejad M. Evaluation of an
effective teaching’s characteristics from
Babol dental faculty postgraduate
students´ viewpoints .Biannual Journal of
Medical Education Education
Development Center (edc). JBUMS Babol
University of Medical Sciences.
2018;6(2):32-8.
13. Zohoor A. Eslaminezhad T. Effective
teaching criteria as viewed by Kerman
University of Medical Sciences' students.
Payesh (Health Monitor). 2002;1(4):5-13.
14. Eslamian H. Evaluation of Application
Measure of Effective Teaching
Components by Faculty Members of
Isfahan University of Medical Science
Based on the of “Student’s Evaluation”
Approach. Teb Va Tazkieh.
2018;27(3):190-203.
15. Tahmasebzadeh Sheikhlar D. Fathiazar E.
Jafarian V. Hamrahzadeh M. Zilabi Gh.
Criteria of Effective Teaching and Its
Application in the Educational Process:
Views of Faculty Members and Students.
Iranian Journal of Medical Education.
2018;18(81):257-268.
16. Sayyadi M. Vahabi A. Vahabi B. Roshani
D. Students' viewpoints on the effective
teaching and related factors in Kurdistan
University of Medical Sciences and
Islamic Azad University, Sanandaj
Branch, 2015. Scientific Journal
of Kurdistan University of Medical
Sciences. 2016;21(1):93-103.
17. Mohammadzadeh N. Vaezi G. Ramezani
Z. Rezaei M. Moradi G. Roshani D.
Defined under the factors related to the
effectiveness of teaching according to
comments of Medical Sciences Students
of Kurdistan University Zanko. Zanko
Journal of Medical Sciences.
2019;15(45):67-75.
18. Darvishpour A. Javadi Pashaki N. Good
clinical instructor from the perspective of
nursing students: a qualitative study.
Journal of Qualitative Research in Health
Sciences. 2019;7(4):372–82.
19. Soroush A. Andaieshgar B. Vahdat A.
Khatony A. The characteristics of an
effective clinical instructor from the
perspective of nursing students: a
qualitative descriptive study in Iran. BMC
Nursing. 2021;20(1):1-9
)